Arthur Fleck Batman Bruce Wayne Cancel culture Columbine Massacre Culture David Berkowitz Dylan Klebold Dylann Roof Elliot Rodger Eric Harris Fashion Incel Joaquin Phoenix Joker mass shootings Oklahoma City Bombing oppression social justice The Joker Thomas Wayne Timothy McVeigh Todd Phillips white supremacy white violence

‘Joker’ Propagates The “Mentally Ill Loner” Narrative Without Introspection or Challenge

“Joker” probably allows males who determine with Arthur Fleck’s descent into violent criminality to seek out not only acceptance, but in addition celebration, empathy, and vindication—and that’s both irresponsible and dangerous. 

This essay incorporates spoilers for “Joker” 

“Amongst many mass killers, the triple privileges of white heterosexual masculinity, which make subsequent life course losses extra sudden and thus more painfully shameful, finally buckle beneath the failures of downward mobility and end in a ultimate cumulative act of violence to stave off subordinated masculinity… White males usually are not systematically disenfranchised, and they also haven’t built up the requisite psychological and emotional mechanisms for dealing with loss.” 

—Triple Entitlement and Homicidal Anger: An Exploration of the Intersectional Identities of American Mass Murderers

Originally of this yr, I had lofty plans to put in writing something about white male terrorism. I knew that the 20th anniversary of the Columbine Bloodbath would fall on April 20, 2019, and just someday before can be the 24th anniversary of the Oklahoma City Bombing. The plan was to ship a retrospective take a look at these occasions via a lens that is not often taken up in mainstream discussions about these acts of terrorism and people who carried them out. A number of issues in my life conspired to stop me from finishing this venture, but that’s neither here nor there at this juncture. Watching “Joker” was a noteworthy reminder that these conversations will all the time be relevant, whether or not they fall adjoining to tragic anniversaries. A lot of the evaluations I’ve learn concerning the movie have primarily declared it to be a uninteresting, hole, and shallow spectacle, “a narrative about nothing” actually. To an extent, I agree. Even so, I feel “Joker” leaves us with lots to discover. Although a good portion of what happens within the film might not even really be occurring—in reality, it is confirmed that at the very least some of what we see is a part of Arthur Fleck’s/Joker’s fantasy world—I consider it is nonetheless worthy of deeper consideration. 

The floor story is a ham-fisted lament and push-back towards “political correctness” and “woke tradition”—as alluded to by Todd Phillips in a current interview. What is understood to the remainder of us as holding individuals accountable for his or her oppressive views and refusing to snort at or with them is seen as a newfangled cage by those that assume that punching down at marginalized individuals is a authentic form of entertainment. They’re more and more extra stifled by this society, by the “PC Police” and “Social Justice Warriors.” It’s an imagined oppression, in fact, especially for Humorous Men like Todd Phillips who really feel like they only aren’t allowed to giggle anymore, a frustration visually represented all through “Joker” by Arthur literally choking on his personal laughter. His condition, Pseudobulbar Affect, causes him to snicker when the rest of society thinks it’s inappropriate for him to take action, and this is used as a purpose to ostracize, isolate, and abuse him. He only stops choking again this laughter once he absolutely embraces nihilistic violence. 

That stated, I don’t agree with the consensus that “Joker” is an incel manifesto. No less than not solely. Fairly, I see it as a mirror for the precise model of violence that is white male terrorism. To be truthful, I utterly perceive why others read Arthur as an incel. He in all probability is one, and the film definitely offers in misogyny. Nevertheless, he by no means explicitly expresses any of the kinds of sentiments about ladies like we’ve heard from Elliot Rodger or David Berkowitz. His lack of ability to have normal social interactions and develop romantic and/or sexual relationships with ladies just isn’t the defining facet of his character, neither is it the rationale he goes on his eventual homicide spree. Though it virtually definitely contributes to it, it’s not what drives him particularly. His violence is extra akin to the type carried out by white men who get “fed up” and persuade themselves that they’re extra disenfranchised than anybody else. The kind of white men who develop into terrified and enraged by the prospect of social progress, which they see as leaving them behind—particularly racial fairness and inclusion—in order that they rail towards the system for all the flawed causes, projecting their rage at figures representative of the buildings they consider are holding them back. Individuals who solely have a “good level” for those who squint, tilt your head and take a look at it in the correct mild, however even then, it’s essential to have deeply-ingrained oppressive ideologies to seek out yourself in agreement with them.  

What a lot of people don’t know concerning the Columbine Massacre—largely on account of misinformation and rumors propagated by the media—is that Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold have been impressed by Oklahoma City bomber, Timothy McVeigh. Particularly, they needed to trigger even more injury, create extra worry, and achieve a better body rely than he did. The Columbine tragedy was not a easy faculty capturing, it was a planned terrorist attack by a narcissistic psychopath and his depressed follower, bullies, and worshippers of Nazi iconography. If the bombs they’d set round the high school had gone off, the casualties would have been closer to what they initially hoped for. The fact that they idolized McVeigh is not any small element to me as a result of McVeigh’s radicalism was rooted in white supremacy. 

On April 19, 1995, 168 individuals died and over 600 have been injured when McVeigh parked a truck bomb in front of the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Constructing. It had been two years to the day because the government siege of the Branch Davidians cult had met a fiery finish in Waco, Texas—which had occurred less than a yr after the deadly siege at Ruby Ridge in Idaho. Both of those occasions came because of government entities in conflict with white supremacists stockpiling weaponry in anticipation of an impending Race Warfare. A tradition of anti-government conspiracist thought and staunch racism from the novel, white separatist “Patriot Motion” is what radicalized McVeigh, however what really set him off was the 1994 Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act, a measure requiring “a waiting interval of 5 days earlier than a licensed importer, producer, or vendor might promote, deliver, or transfer a handgun to an unlicensed individual.” 


Individuals like McVeigh could also be towards government management, however only as a result of they are satisfied the federal government is coming to take their guns and depart them at an obstacle in conflicts with individuals of colour, a future they see as inevitable. Their oppression is an imagined one and their rage is a byproduct of their racial nervousness. They worry the lack of institutional energy. In the long run, McVeigh was largely considered a “mentally sick loner” and the white supremacist motivations behind his actions turned misplaced in mainstream understandings of the bombing, which is usually understood be only anti-government by those who don’t know the complete story. That is what I see mirrored in “Joker.” 

Let me be clear. Joker is a supervillain and he behaves like a supervillain. His character is just as violent and unhinged as I anticipate him to be. That isn’t what’s problematic about this latest take on the Clown Prince’s story. The problem is that it tries extremely exhausting to make us feel dangerous for Arthur Fleck, and Joker by extension, which in flip makes his vengeance really feel justified. The film irresponsibly affirms Joker as a sympathetic figure and propagates the “mentally sick loner” narrative in a means that mirrors real-world narratives about white mass shooters and domestic terrorists. 

Arthur’s existence as a downtrodden loner is strengthened at each turn, it’s inescapable. He’s relegated to a menial job as a clown for hire resulting from his off-putting conduct and mental illness. Whereas working a gig twirling an “Every little thing Should Go!” signal, he’s harassed, has his sign stolen, and is physically assaulted by a gaggle of brown youths who his coworker later refers to as “savages” and “animals”—which feels fairly indicative of racial anxieties to me. Then, he is accosted by an indignant Black lady on the bus for innocently making her son snicker—in truth, most of the individuals hooked up to the moments and situations through which Arthur is/feels unfairly treated, misunderstood, or invisible are Black ladies, which I’d say can also be fairly revealing. Soon after this, he’s physically assaulted whereas in clown costume once more—this time by a gaggle of wealthy, drunken white men who’ve simply sexually harassed a lady on the subway. He finally ends up killing them. After this, Arthur continues to experience blow after blow, stressor after stressor. The dangerous information and unjust experiences simply hold piling up increasingly, culminating in him being unemployed, without entry to psychological health providers or medicine, with new surprising details about his past that reveals much more abuse and abandonment, and leaves him feeling finally alone on the earth and without id.

After the subway murders, the individuals who have been already being vocal and hanging towards Gotham’s privileged elite like Thomas Wayne (father of Bruce Wayne, the eventual Batman and Joker’s arch-nemesis) begin sporting clown masks to emulate the unknown “vigilante” whom they assume killed the Wall Road bullies as a political assertion. What additionally helps to precipitate this is the fact that Thomas Wayne himself speaks out towards the killings and, in true fascist scum style, provides the dissenters a derogatory label: clowns. Because of witnessing this embrace of his image as a logo of resistance, regardless that nobody knows he is the one behind the clown make-up, Arthur begins to seek out an importance in his existence that he never felt before. He tells his social employee, “For my entire life, I didn’t know if I even really existed. However I do, and individuals are beginning to notice.”

By the top, what “Joker” achieves—whether or not deliberately or not—is a blurring of the strains between the anti-capitalist, anti-fascist, anti-cop, anti-establishment rebellion by the poor, working-class residents of Gotham and Joker’s self-centered, nihilistic, anarchist vengeance. The rationale Joker is heralded as a hero, in the long run, is because the rioters venture their beliefs onto him and align their frustrations together with his. They do not know that his homicide of the three men on the subway had absolutely nothing to do with them being rich jerks, however was as an alternative an act of pointed retaliation for what they did to him. He might have shot the primary two in self-defense, however the third, he hunted down and emptied his clip into with intention and malice. The rioters don’t know that his conduct on Murray Franklin’s present is a direct response to him mocking Joker’s dangerous stand-up routine, not a political assertion about socioeconomic disparities in Gotham. His actions are rooted in his own narcissism and insulated worldview, not in solidarity with the rest of the working poor and their rightful anger. 

“What do you get if you cross a mentally unwell loner with a society that abandons him and treats him like trash?” he asks Murray. “I’ll inform you what you get. You get what you fucking deserve.”

“Joker” lazily makes use of the same harmful logic and reasoning that has been used for this type of violence since Columbine. If solely these “mentally sick loner[s]” might have been helped by society, if solely they hadn’t been bullied and treated like trash. These are the gaslighting sentiments we hear repeatedly, fairly than individuals taking a tough take a look at the truth of white male violence, what motivates it, and what radicalizes them. 

The film is described by the studio as an “exploration of a man disregarded by society [that] shouldn’t be only a gritty character research but in addition a broader cautionary tale.” But there isn’t a caution to be discovered. Because it exists, the film feels more like an honoring of the character the filmmakers declare to only research. It does no work to problem Joker’s perception that he’s justified, and as an alternative offers him with a sea of (actual or imagined) cheering fanatics who search to emulate him. “Joker” probably allows men who determine with Arthur Fleck’s descent into violent criminality to seek out not solely acceptance, but in addition celebration, empathy, and vindication—and that is both irresponsible and harmful. 

Every single dollar matters to us—especially now when media is beneath constant menace. Your help is important and your generosity is why Wear Your Voice keeps going! You’re part of the resistance that’s wanted—uplifting Black and brown feminists via your pledges is the direct group help that permits us to make more room for marginalized voices. For as little as $1 each month you could be a part of this journey with us. This platform is our means of creating essential and constructive change, and together we will continue to grow.

Be a part of Wear Your Voice on Patreon


(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); = id;
js.src = “//join.fb.internet/en_US/sdk.js#xfbml=1&version=v2.5”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));